April 5, 2018
High court ruling cuts manslaughter term in half
Carroll “Tootie” Gregg leaves the Fauquier courthouse after his convictions on two manslaughter charges in December 2018.
I am relieved that the Supreme Court ultimately agreed with the decision of the court of appeals. And I agree with that decision.
— Defense attorney Blair Howard
The state’s highest court Thursday ruled that a Marshall man convicted of involuntary manslaughter will spend will spend 10 — rather 20 — years in prison for the crime.
A Fauquier County Circuit Court jury in December 2105 convicted Carroll E. “Tootie” Gregg Jr. of two homicide charges in the shooting death of a tow truck driver.
The jury recommended a 10-year sentence on each manslaughter conviction. Judge Herman A. Whisenant Jr. exercised a state code provision to add three years on each conviction.
Judge Whisenant sentenced Mr. Gregg to 26 years in prison, with six years suspended.
He shot and killed Junior Jordan Montero Sanchez, 23, just after midnight June 6, 2014. Mr. Sanchez and a towing company coworker had gone to Mr. Gregg’s apartment on Conde Road to repossess a pickup truck for delinquent loan payments.
But, the Virginia Supreme Court’s ruling April 5 effectively voids one of the convictions — eliminating a 10-year sentence.
The court concluded that Mr. Gregg's sentences violated the U.S and Virginia constitutions’ “double jeopardy” provisions, which protect individuals from getting punished twice for the same crime.
“Involuntary manslaughter under (the pertinent Virginia Code section) is the ‘same offense’ as common law involuntary manslaughter,” the ruling states. “We therefore conclude that Gregg was twice convicted and sentenced in the same trial of the same offense . . . in violation of the Double Jeopardy Clause.”
“This should make a big difference in his life,” Warrenton lawyer Blair Howard, who represents the 56-year-old Mr. Gregg, said of the Supreme Court’s decision. “He’s still a young man.
“I am very pleased and grateful for Mr. Gregg and his family.”
Mr. Gregg has remained behind bars since his June 2014 arrest. Because that “time served” counts toward the sentence, his client has about four years and nine months left of the remaining 10-year term, according to Warrenton lawyer T. Blair Howard II.
If not for the Supreme Court ruling, Mr. Gregg would face another 16 years in prison.
“I am relieved that the Supreme Court ultimately agreed with the decision of the court of appeals,” Blair Howard said. “And I agree with that decision.”
At the trial, the defense immediately objected to the pair of manslaughter sentences, arguing they violated U.S. and Virginia’s “double jeopardy” clauses.
In December 2016, a Virginia Court of Appeals panel agreed.
But, seeking to uphold Mr. Gregg’s pair of convictions and sentences, the state attorney general’s office appealed that decision to the Virginia Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in the case March 2.
The seven justices unanimously affirmed the appeals court’s ruling. In doing so, it sent the case back to the circuit court, where the prosecution will choose which conviction to apply.
“The court clarified the law for us on this issue which is important for future cases,” Fauquier Commonwealth’s Attorney James P. Fisher said of the ruling. “The reality is that prior to this decision, there was precious little case law on how to determine legislative intent permitting multiple punishments for different crimes.
“This is a bit of a landmark decision because the court synthesized a large body of cases and distilled a clear, easily applicable precedent for the future.”
The attorney general’s office handles most appeals of criminal cases that start with local prosecutor.
Mr. Fisher had argued that the vehicle shooting conviction has different elements, even though state code labels it “involuntary manslaughter.”
But Blair Howard believed his client had a strong case.
“When we left Richmond (where the Supreme Court heard the oral argument), I thought we put on as good a case as we could.”
Gregg Virginia Supreme Court Ruling 4 5 2018 by Fauquier Now on Scribd
Please, be polite. Avoid name-calling and profanity.
For credibility, sign your real name; stand behind your comments. Readers will give less credence to anonymous posts.
Enter your email address above to begin receiving
news updates from FauquierNow.com via email.
Friday, April 20
Kiley M. Gonzalez allegedly took about $8,000 from organization at Grace Miller Elementary School in Bealeton
Friday, April 20
Szydlowski joins Denim & Pearls, theatre hires Smyers, small business survey, free homebuyer class and Valor Awards next week
More Fauquier news
Friday, April 20
Although long expected, store’s demise will leave huge vacant space in challenging retail environment